Liz got a mysterious bouquet of flowers on Valentine's Day. She wanted to know who sent them. She suspected Jack, but he assured her it wasn't him. He was too busy wanting to celebrate the final stages of his divorce. The rest of the crew were upset because they had to pull an all-nighter to write the rest of the show.
Jack took Tracy out to celebrate under the condition that Tracy would be back at 10 that night to catch dinner reservations he made for him and his wife for Valentine's Day. Later on, when he tried to leave Jack's side, Jack accused him of being weak. Tracy left, but told Jack he knew where to find him if he needed him.
Jenna finally called Frank out on his meanness towards her. She wanted to know what his problem was. He told her she was a big phony and everything about her was a big fake. He told her everything she's ever said has never been genuine or real. They eventually made up, only when she accidentally farted in front of Frank and admitted she's a real person.
Tracy was in the middle of a romantic evening with his wife, but the night was ruined when a drunk Jack stopped by with a prostitute he met at a deli. Tracy's wife ordered Tracy to get rid of Jack and his companion. Tracy had no choice but to call Liz.
The guys had Kenneth convinced that Cerie had a thing for him. Kenneth walked Cerie outside to get candy and when they were finished, she wanted to linger. She asked for advice on how to handle her fiancé. She misread Kenneth's advice and decided to meet her fiancé downtown. Kenneth tried to open mouth kiss her, but she just laughed it off and gave Kenneth permission to tell guys that they made out.
Liz was relaxing after pulling an all-nighter at work. A lawyer from NBC came by looking for the flowers that were delivered. He told her the flowers were meant for his girlfriend and accidentally sent to Liz instead. He then wished her a Happy Valentine's Day and let her keep the flowers.